I rarely get excited about FPS games
I loved the first Bioshock and played it through twice back-to-back to experiment with the endings and multiple approaches. But I still haven't gotten around to Bioshock 2 as I can't quite appreciate the concept of being a Big Daddy plus the aesthetics and gameplay just make the game look more of an expansion pack than a stand alone game which can be defined on its own merits.
But the third game does look really good, it could rival the first one.
But the third game does look really good, it could rival the first one.