Page 1 of 1

Question regarding posting music to the downloads

Posted: June 21, 2012 • 10:09 am
by gryphonosiris
I have the complete Overseer soundtrack and I'm wondering if it is ok (see legal) for me to post all of it to the music downloads section?

Re: Question regarding posting music to the downloads

Posted: June 21, 2012 • 10:19 am
by KMFDMvsEnya
You could email BFG and ask for permission. I do not believe it was released through a record company so CJ & AC should hold the rights to the music.

If you do could you provide it as flac rather than mp3?

Best Regards
KvE

Re: Question regarding posting music to the downloads

Posted: June 21, 2012 • 10:26 am
by gryphonosiris
Someone beat me to it, it's already there, but it's 77 Mb, which make me wonder about the quality.

Re: Question regarding posting music to the downloads

Posted: June 21, 2012 • 11:16 am
by Demonlawyer
It probably depends on ownership and who owns the rights to the music. Richie Havens and Matt Heider may hold the rights or it could be AC and CJ depending on what was agreed.

I've never seen anyone mind sharing things here, especially if it increases awareness of Tex/Matt/Richie's work etc, but always best to ask to be safe.

Re: Question regarding posting music to the downloads

Posted: June 21, 2012 • 12:34 pm
by dcat151
The technical (although, not popular) answer is that without the copyright holder's permission it is copyright infringement to copy, distribute, publish, etc. the music.

Re: Question regarding posting music to the downloads

Posted: June 21, 2012 • 6:06 pm
by Cubase
dcat151 wrote:The technical (although, not popular) answer is that without the copyright holder's permission it is copyright infringement to copy, distribute, publish, etc. the music.
Yes... hence why the database I have of the Tex Murphy OSTs neglects to include the tracks from the Overseer soundtrack CD, but it does everything else, including unreleased pieces from the game. Only because Matt Heider gave me permission to host them.

-Cub. =o)

Re: Question regarding posting music to the downloads

Posted: June 21, 2012 • 7:49 pm
by joliet_jane
I say, upload them and let a mod sort it out. Users aren't lawyers and shouldn't be expected to be, and users are not running the site.

Re: Question regarding posting music to the downloads

Posted: June 21, 2012 • 11:38 pm
by Demonlawyer
I noticed Matt was an early backer so he's still about if you message him.

Re: Question regarding posting music to the downloads

Posted: June 22, 2012 • 3:05 am
by Vae Victis
joliet_jane wrote:I say, upload them and let a mod sort it out. Users aren't lawyers and shouldn't be expected to be, and users are not running the site.
If you would do that, the damage would already be done in case it's not allowed.
In my opinion a big no.

Beside all that, even with permission I still wouldn't do it. Cause it would undermine the tex memorabilia drawing
The Overseer soundtrack is part of that.

Re: Question regarding posting music to the downloads

Posted: June 22, 2012 • 7:01 am
by dcat151
joliet_jane wrote:I say, upload them and let a mod sort it out. Users aren't lawyers and shouldn't be expected to be, and users are not running the site.
Well, some users are lawyers. :wink:

However, I don't think the "I'm not a lawyer defense" goes very far.